About Annabel s
Hello! I'm the Annabel behind Annabel's.
I've always been a cake person, obsessed with the idea and image of it - from the chocolate monstrosity in Matilda to Hagrid's lopsided birthday cake for Harry.
After taking a cake-decorating course at JoAnn's (RIP) in my early teens, I hadn't given making my own cakes much thought until I decided to make my own wedding cake in 2024, reigniting my love for the craft.
Whether you're celebrating a milestone or simply wanting to treat yourself to something sweet, I'm here to make your vision come to life.
Let's make cake people of us all!
Client Testimonials
Emily B.
Annabel made the most beautiful cake for my baby shower! The flavors were a perfect blend of sweetness and citrus and the flower decoration was a show stopper. Would recommend to anyone looking for a statement piece at their party
Jenny L.
Annabel helped us decide between three different types of cakes & flavors for our wedding cake. The experience was personalized with every detail thought out. Her cakes are equally as delicious as they are beautiful.
Aris P.
When I want a cake for a special occasion, I want someone who understands what flavors I like, what the occasion calls for, and who puts a unique, creative spin into each order. Annabel's cakes do exactly that - they're beautiful, always delicious, and made with the same effort that she would put in if she were baking for her family.
Sizing and Flavors
Cake Sizing
Round Cakes
6"
6" Dome
8"
8" Dome
9"
10"
Starting at
$65
$75
$90
$100
$115
$135
Sheet Cakes
Quarter sheet
Half sheet
Full sheet
Starting at
$75
$80
$100
Etc.
6" Heart-shaped
starting at
$70
Cake Flavors
Vanilla
Almond
Lemon
Olive Oil
Coconut
Coffee
Earl Grey
Chocolate
Carrot
Banana
Berry
& More
Gluten-free mod (+$10)
Vegan mod (+$15)
Frostings and Fillings
Swiss Meringue Buttercream
vanilla, chocolate, peanut butter, honey, fruit-flavored, pistachio, tea, coffee, caramel, coconut, miso, herb, floral, liqueur, etc.!
Whipped Ganache
dark/milk/white chocolate, caramel
Cream Cheese Frosting
Whipped Cream Frosting
Jam/Curd
Ganache
Fresh Fruit
Streusel
Non-Dairy Buttercream
Non-Dairy Whipped Cream
Order Form
Use this form to request future cake orders. Please allow 48 hours for a response. Requests will be accepted based on our availability.
Once your order is accepted, we will send an invoice via email. All invoices must be paid 1 week before your pickup date.
Pick-up is in the Cottage Home neighborhood in downtown Indy. Delivery is available for free within the boundaries of I-465; delivery outside that range will incur a $10-20 fee dependent on distance traveled.
Thank you!
